This comparative post from Kate Hendrix is a WOW.
Henkes, K. (2007). A good day. New York, NY: Greenwillow Books.
Kevin Henkes’s delightful picture book for very young children A Good Day follows
a series of colorful animal characters (a little yellow bird, a little
brown squirrel, a little orange fox, and a little white dog) and a
little girl through what begins as a bad day, as defined by a string of
unfortunate events, but that turns “good” when good fortune comes their
way. In contrast to Lilly’s Big Day’s slightly more complicated word choice and sentence structure and more elaborate plot, A Good Day’s large typeface and extremely simple word choice and sentence structure make the book perfect for adults to read to toddlers. Nearly
every page where text appears contains only one short sentence, and
even the illustrations are drawn to contain a large depiction of each of
the animals and the little girl in their uncomplicated settings. Colors are bold, and lines are thick, but Henkes manages to capture the emotions of each moment.
I explained in the blog below for Lilly’s Big Day why I chose these books by Kevin Henkes and found this one to be an interesting one to use as a comparison piece. While Lilly’s Big Day had a more complex plot and matching illustrations that would work well for young elementary-age students (K-2), A Good Day was clearly written to appeal to slightly younger eyes. Because
the animals are all different colors, the book not only teaches the
lesson that even the worst day can turn out to be “a good day” with a
little change in perspective, but it also teaches children colors and
helps them learn to decode the words that correspond with the color. It can appeal to many ages, so I will recommend this book to my sister-in-law as one that she could read with 3 year-old. Perhaps, her oldest daughter, a six-year-old, might even be able to read it to her little sister! It might be a fun sister bonding experience.
While A Good Day
is a great book for young children to read and learn from, it was a
tough one to think of a way that I might be able to use it in my Pre-AP
Sophomore English class…maybe I could use it to demonstrate the basic
simple sentence then ask students to elaborate on the sentence, adding
more and more detail to make it more complex for an older audience.
Such musings lead to my BIG QUESTION…Using the illustration on the
facing page as inspiration, how can you make the sentence about the
little yellow bird’s misfortune more complex by adding descriptive words
and phrases?
Henkes, K. (2006). Lilly’s big day. New York, NY: Greenwillow Books.
When
Lilly’s teacher Mr. Slinger announces to his class that he will soon
marry the school nurse, Ms. Shotwell, Lilly excitedly assumes she’ll be
the flower girl. Her dreams are
dashed when Mr. Slinger informs her that his niece Ginger will be
taking on that job, but, to make her feel better, he asks Lilly if she’d
be willing to act as Ginger’s assistant. Lilly somewhat reluctantly agrees. At the wedding, an interesting turn of events occurs that places Lilly in an important role, but you’ll just have to read Lilly’s Big Day to find out what happens!
Henkes
provides a writing style that is easy to read but not “dumbed down,”
using words that might be familiar to early elementary school students. He uses simple dialogue and parallel structure to draw his readers in whether they’re reading aloud or silently. As
a high school teacher, I don’t really know how much I could actually
use this book in my classroom (my kids might be a tad insulted at
first), but I might be able to use it to teach parallel structure – how
to write it and to illustrate why it’s effective for readers of all
ages.
Complementing the text are the charming, cartoon-style watercolor and black pen illustrations for Lilly’s Big Day that are the creation of author Kevin Henkes. As is the case with the definition of picture books, the illustrations do more than just reiterate the events of the plot. They
add to the plot of the story and flesh out the mouse characters through
clever facial expressions, colorful settings, and additional dialogue
within the pictures. Some of my
favorite moments occur when an unnamed little boy mouse in Lilly’s
class reacts with, “Yuck!” when Mr. Slinger announces his engagement
then remarks in a later illustration, “I’m never getting married.” It’s little details like this that made this book so enjoyable to read.
I
have no children of my own and, as mentioned above, I teach high
school, but, when I told my sisters-in-law that I was taking a course in
Children’s and Young Adult Literature, they asked that I keep an eye
out for books that they could share with their kids, my nieces and
nephews. In my selections of
books, then, I have been on the lookout not only for young adult
literature for my students but also for excellent children’s book ideas
for them. To be honest, the
primary reason I chose to read this particular book is that it was
mentioned in our text for the course and was one of several others
listed by the same author and it fit the age-group of a few of my nieces
and nephews. I figured that,
if this author had written so many books that had been recommended by
people who know great children’s literature, he must be excellent! I
certainly was not disappointed, and I will most definitely share this
book with the moms in my family for all the reasons above, but also
because of its valuable themes of friendship, support, and understanding
and grace when things don’t quite go your way. Also,
I wanted to read several books by the same author so that I could
compare his style across different texts, as recommended on our course
syllabus. My next blog post will actually deal with another one of Kevin Henkes’s books.
BIG
QUESTION for the little ones: When in your life have you had an
experience that someone else got to do something that you wanted to do? How did you handle it? After reading Lilly’s Big Day, how might you handle it differently?
BIG QUESTION for older students: How do the illustrations add to the plot and characterization in Lilly’s Big Day?
No comments:
Post a Comment