Here are some previous student reflections. I BOLDED the writing that let me know they were learning the lingo.
Tough Cookie by Wisniewski, David – Picture Book
First I want to say that I think Tough Cookie is a very cute book. I love the “map” on the first pages. The writing and illustrations for this book are very creative. I’m always impressed by authors who can turn everyday mundane things into interesting books. The cut paper illustrations are vivid and complex. I’ve thumbed through the book a few times and usually find some cute little detail I hadn’t noticed before tucked into a corner. The protagonist is indeed a “tough cookie” of the Dick Tracy variety. We see through flashback that he has dealt with the dreaded antagonist Fingers before. The climax and conclusion of this book are quite surprising and place previously flat characters in very important positions.
Joyful Noise: Poems for two Voices by Paul Fleischman was a very enjoyable read. I found myself wishing that I had someone to read them out with me. I love how the poems bring the insects to life. Living in the country I know all too well about the noises the insects and many other creatures make. I love to hear there songs as I drift off to sleep in the spring and summer. The illustrations in Joyful Noise are magnificent. The black and white pencil drawings are incredibly detailed and filled with movement and texture. The surrealism used in some of the illustrations adds to the wonderful quirkiness of the book.
After reading “Pictures of Hollis Woods” I feel that many teens would enjoy reading this book. Reasons range from the general attractions such as a book that is well written and deals with feelings and emotions that most teens experience, to more specific attributes of the plot that will attract specific readerships. I think that most teens experience feelings of being left out, spitefulness, depression, resentfulness, and many of the other emotions that Hollis goes through. More specifically teens that are foster children, artists, adopted, or watching a loved one suffer through the affects of old age will be interested in this book because they will be able to relate to it on a more personal level. A theme that stood out to me in this book is that as humans we often express more than we intend to express in our “art.” While Hollis was drawing literal pictures of the world around her she was also drawing subjective portraits of herself. Perhaps this book appeals to me more than others because I am an artist and I feel that in the best art we can see the artist and how he or she was feeling when they created the piece. I also grew up in a house where my parents had adopted two children and I have two uncles that have had Alzheimer’s disease. (Giff et al, 2002)
Tough Cookie by Wisniewski, David – Picture Book
First I want to say that I think Tough Cookie is a very cute book. I love the “map” on the first pages. The writing and illustrations for this book are very creative. I’m always impressed by authors who can turn everyday mundane things into interesting books. The cut paper illustrations are vivid and complex. I’ve thumbed through the book a few times and usually find some cute little detail I hadn’t noticed before tucked into a corner. The protagonist is indeed a “tough cookie” of the Dick Tracy variety. We see through flashback that he has dealt with the dreaded antagonist Fingers before. The climax and conclusion of this book are quite surprising and place previously flat characters in very important positions.
Joyful Noise: Poems for two Voices by Paul Fleischman was a very enjoyable read. I found myself wishing that I had someone to read them out with me. I love how the poems bring the insects to life. Living in the country I know all too well about the noises the insects and many other creatures make. I love to hear there songs as I drift off to sleep in the spring and summer. The illustrations in Joyful Noise are magnificent. The black and white pencil drawings are incredibly detailed and filled with movement and texture. The surrealism used in some of the illustrations adds to the wonderful quirkiness of the book.
After reading “Pictures of Hollis Woods” I feel that many teens would enjoy reading this book. Reasons range from the general attractions such as a book that is well written and deals with feelings and emotions that most teens experience, to more specific attributes of the plot that will attract specific readerships. I think that most teens experience feelings of being left out, spitefulness, depression, resentfulness, and many of the other emotions that Hollis goes through. More specifically teens that are foster children, artists, adopted, or watching a loved one suffer through the affects of old age will be interested in this book because they will be able to relate to it on a more personal level. A theme that stood out to me in this book is that as humans we often express more than we intend to express in our “art.” While Hollis was drawing literal pictures of the world around her she was also drawing subjective portraits of herself. Perhaps this book appeals to me more than others because I am an artist and I feel that in the best art we can see the artist and how he or she was feeling when they created the piece. I also grew up in a house where my parents had adopted two children and I have two uncles that have had Alzheimer’s disease. (Giff et al, 2002)